Home News Rising Consumer Credit Levels: A Potential Sign of Economic Downturn?

Rising Consumer Credit Levels: A Potential Sign of Economic Downturn?


Former chair of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), Sheila Bair, has raised concerns about the current record-high consumer credit levels. While many experts are divided on whether this is a cause for concern, the recent report by the Federal Reserve sheds light on the situation.

In November, total consumer credit experienced its most significant increase in a year, with a rise of $23.7 billion. This surge pushed consumers’ outstanding credit to over $5 trillion, an unprecedented figure in history. It’s important to note that this data does not include mortgage loans, which represent the largest portion of household debt.

Bair voiced her hope that this surge is merely a temporary blip tied to the holiday season, with consumers able to pay off their debts. However, there are differing opinions on the matter. Mark Zandi, the chief economist at Moody’s Analytics, sees a silver lining, emphasizing that Americans’ credit quality has actually improved.

Zandi asserts that household credit quality is stabilizing, offering some reassurance amidst the concerns. It remains to be seen how this situation will unfold and whether it will have any implications for the overall economy.

The Growing Consumer Credit Landscape

Consumer credit levels have reached an all-time high, surpassing the $5 trillion mark for the first time ever. This remarkable milestone raises questions about the potential impact on the economy. While some believe it could be a mere blip tied to seasonal spending, others remain cautious.

Concerns and Optimism

Sheila Bair, former FDIC chair, highlights the alarming nature of this phenomenon, cautioning that high consumer debt levels have historically been precursors to economic downturns. However, Mark Zandi brings a contrasting perspective, asserting that Americans’ credit quality has shown signs of improvement.

Assessing the Situation

The Federal Reserve’s recent report paints a vivid picture of the current consumer credit landscape. With a significant $23.7 billion increase in total consumer credit during November, it’s evident that borrowing is on the rise. Notably, this data excludes mortgage loans, which play a major role in household debt.

What Lies Ahead

As the debate rages on about the implications of growing consumer credit levels, only time will reveal the true impact on the economy. Will this surge be a temporary blip or a hint at possible economic downturns? The coming months will shed light on whether consumers can comfortably manage their debts or if further concerns are warranted.

Household Debt Delinquency Rates on the Decline

Equifax data reveals that household debt delinquency rates have seen a decrease, while the growth rate of total outstanding household debt has been consistently falling throughout 2023.

Encouraging Trends in Household Debt

Economist Mark Zandi has expressed optimism regarding these trends, highlighting the positive impact of tighter underwriting standards following last year’s banking crisis. Zandi believes that this slowdown in household debt growth, combined with low unemployment rates and Federal Reserve rate cuts, will ultimately lead to lower delinquency rates by mid-year.

Consumer Credit on a Downward Trend

Since the Federal Reserve’s aggressive rate hikes and tighter lending standards implemented by banks, consumer credit has followed a downward trajectory. However, there are certain categories of debt that are showing warning signs.

Worries of Mounting Credit Card Debt

The total amount of credit card debt accumulated by Americans reached record highs in 2023, raising concerns among experts. While the overall trend is decreasing, credit card debt remains a significant area of focus.

The Rise of “Phantom Debt”

Another emerging concern revolves around the extensive utilization of “buy now, pay later” services. Although this type of debt does not currently appear on credit reports, it still impacts consumers’ financial well-being. In fact, U.S. shoppers set a new record with $16.6 billion in buy-now-pay-later purchases during the recent holiday season, reflecting a 14% increase compared to the previous year.

In summary, while household debt delinquency rates are declining and overall debt growth is slowing down, potential warning signs persist in the form of record-breaking credit card debt and the rise of “phantom debt” resulting from buy now, pay later services.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

  +  89  =  99